Pit boss Griddle vs Blackstone Griddle | Griddle Comparison in 2022

pit boss griddle vs blackstone griddle1

Why you should buy a griddle instead of a traditional grill model? for your breakfast to cook pancakes, bacon, hash browns, patties, and eggs at the same time, the griddle with a larger cooking area gives you the facility to make a large number of items at one time. You can buy a flat top griddle at a reasonable price. The stainless steel constructed griddles are durable and sturdy. Some models are shaped rectangular and have side and back walls to protect the food. Some models are rounded in shape and open from the backside.

Cook all items on large size griddle easier and faster. It has a better grease management system and high temperature setting options. Here we will discuss the two reputed brands of griddles, Blackstone and pit boss. We will compare their features so that you buy the best griddle easily.

Pit boss griddle vs Blackstone griddle

Cooking area

When you have to choose the griddle, you will first compare the cooking area of the griddle. The cooking area is the capacity of the griddle to cook food. How much food you can cook on its surface. In this post, the pit boss has a cooking surface of 289 square inches, and the Blackstone gives you a cooking surface of 339 square inches.

It means that these griddles are of medium size. The pit boss griddle comes with a 4.7mm thick nonstick surface, and the Blackstone has a cold-rolled steel griddle top which heats up quickly and is best for even heat. Use these griddle to make breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Winner: Blackstone griddle due to cooking surface of 339 square inches

Material

If you want to be able to cook with your griddle outside the house or in the backyard, then it must be made from a material that can withstand high temperatures, which means it should be made from a substantial and durable material.

Both of these griddles are not only made of excellent materials, but they are also very sturdy and well-constructed. The Blackstone griddle is almost entirely made of stainless steel, and the company is well known for producing products of high quality.

The construction of this griddle is very sturdy, which may carry the risk of making the griddle feel too heavy, but on the other hand, it can allow the griddle to stay in place while cooking. At the time of the locking of the wheels, the vehicle does not make any movements.

Although the Blackstone griddle has a sturdy build, it can collapse the legs, so there is no need to worry about taking up too much space when in a car or pickup truck.

The same holds for the Pit Boss griddle, for it is evident from the outset that it is almost entirely made up of stainless steel, except for the cooking surface, which has a standard surface. The legs of the table are very thin, but they are also very sturdy.

There are some foldable shelves in the Pit Boss griddle, but other than that, there are not many other things that can be done to make it portable. Unfortunately, there is no handle on the griddle’s surface, so it isn’t easy to lift the Pit Boss griddle.

Insofar as their build quality is concerned, I think both of these griddle models are of the same quality in terms of durability and sturdiness. Still, I believe the Blackstone griddle is the clear winner in its portability.

Temperature Control

The Blackstone griddle is perfect for Pitmasters who cook for large crowds regularly since it has a wide griddle that can accommodate large amounts of food. Yet, it gives you the ability to control the temperature in different griddle parts.

On top of that, you can also use a griddle for cooking a variety of foods that are not possible to cook on a grill. With the flat griddle plate, you can not only prepare breakfast foods such as eggs, bacon, pancakes, and hash browns, but you can also cook Teppanyaki-style alongside classic cookout foods such as hamburgers, sausages, and steak.

Different settings can be adjusted on the temperature controller of each Pit Boss Grill. You will find several temperature settings on most controllers, including Smoke, 200°F, 225°F, 250°F, 300°F, 350°F, 400°F, 475°F, and “High.”

When a Pit Boss is set to smoke or high temperature, the ambient temperature of the grill does not affect the timing of the drill when the temperature is set to those settings.

Heat distribution

To cook other foods, such as vegetables, that are not too heat-sensitive, the griddles can reach a high temperature on one side while maintaining a constant temperature on the other side.

In the Pit Boss griddle, four burners are evenly distributed over the entire cooking surface. Three straight burners are located on the right-hand side of the range, and a U-shaped burner is located on the left.

This is because there is another feature on the side of the burner that requires a bit more space to be accommodated. The four powerful burners on this stove will allow you to simultaneously heat a large cooking surface.

The Blackstone griddle also has four burners. Consequently, the four burners can also be spread evenly across the 35-inch cooking area of the griddle to enable the griddle to heat up quickly and uniformly while maintaining its settings.

Blackstone griddle does not have U-shaped burners due to the fact that each of the straight burners is capable of generating 15,000 BTUs evenly across the surface. There will always be an even heat distribution over the large surface area of the cooking surface.

Burners

Both griddles have two independent burners with adjustable heat control dials. The pit boss heats the entire cooking surface with 15000BTUs of power, and the Blackstone delivers 24000 BTUs of heat through its H-style burners. H style burners are helpful to provide even heat over the entire surface.

They also come with an electronic ignition button for quick and easy lighting of burners.

Winner: Blackstone griddle due to 24000 BTUs

Cooking surface material

When it comes to comparing the cooking surface material, the pit boss cooking top made with cast iron and Blackstone comes with heat-rolled steel that is more durable and heavyweight.

The cast-iron surface takes less time to heat up, so you can save fuel. The food will be cooked in less time than Blackstone griddle.

Winner: Pit boss griddle due to used cast iron surface it take less time to heat up

Sturdy construction

The griddle should be made with high-quality material, so if you go for tailgating and camping, then they can with stand high temperature and extreme weather situations. Both griddles are solidly constructed. The pit boss is made with stainless steel and its griddle of cast iron, whereas the Blackstone is fully made with stainless steel material. You may consider it a heavyweight griddle, but it is built to last for a long time.

The pit boss is perfect size griddle made for tailgating. It comes with non-slip tabletop feet to place it on any surface. It is lightweight, can be placed in a car, and is easily carried for travel.

Winner: Pit boss griddle due to lightweight

Versatile

Which is more versatile; both have two burners and medium-size griddles. On the griddle surface, you will cook fry and sauté vegetables to make pancakes and seared steaks. You can cook any meal for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The cast iron griddle of the pit boss retains more heat and distributes heat evenly, so it is best for thicker pieces of meat. It takes less time to cook steaks.

Winner – Both

Cleaning

When cleaning the griddle, clean them after cooking when the surface is warm. The pit boss has a grease catcher tray that is easy to clean. The Blackstone also has a grease management system for quick cleaning. You just need to clean the grease-catching tray.

Both griddles have holes on their cooking surface. Use a spatula to throw the oil from one hole to the grease tray, then remove the excess grease with a towel.

Which is best for you?

The Blackstone griddle is a better choice if you consider between that and the Pit Boss griddle, which I would suggest you go with. They have been proving their models to be excellent for quite some time now.

The Blackstone griddle is almost entirely made of stainless steel, and the company is known for producing products of high quality.

Pit boss griddle vs Blackstone griddle: Reviews

PIT BOSS 2 Burner Table Top LP Gas Griddle

PIT BOSS 2 Burner Table Top LP Gas Griddle

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

Pit boss perfect size grill for outdoors to cook a large number of items on the griddle. The lightweight grill is used for tailgating and camping. This griddle has non slippery four legs. You can set it on the table.4.7mm thick griddle surface, which is heavy and per-seasoned with organic oil. after use, you can clean it easily with a towel.

The pit boss has 289 square inches of cooking surface with two independent control burners. The griddle size is large enough to cook up to four people at the same time. the cast iron griddle is easy to clean

Cook everything from eggs to pancakes, bacon steaks, and burgers. Built-in ignition button for quick and easy start-up. In this griddle, you can set the heat from high to low. cook food quickly at high temperature of the griddle.

Pros
  • Cast iron griddle heats up quickly
  • Heavy durable, and easy to clean
  • Adjustable legs
  • Grease drain out properly
Cons
  • it is difficult to turn down the heat
  • uneven heat

Blackstone 1666 Tabletop Griddle

Blackstone 1666 Tabletop Griddle

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

Blackstone has been producing griddles since 2005 and is the market leader. Blackstone assembled their griddles in the USA. The 22″ tabletop griddle with two burners. You can control the heat level of the burner from high to low. The flat-top griddle is 339 square inches.

With the h style burners for even heat across all grilling surfaces, you can make delicious hot dogs, eggs burgers. There is a large grease tray that collects all grease from food, and thus the cooking process will be clean. You can attach a 1lb propane bottle or 20 lb propane tank. the electronic ignition button to fire up the burners easily and quickly.

Find out: Best Blackstone Grills

Pros
  • The h burners spread the heat evenly
  • Simple and easy setup
  • Clean up is very easy
Cons
  • No handles to move it
  • The ignitor button does not work properly

Comparison Table Pit Boss Griddle Vs Blackstone Griddle

Choice
PIT BOSS PB336GS Two Burner Portable Flat Top Griddle - Cover Included
Winner
Blackstone Tabletop Griddle, 1666, Heavy Duty Flat Top Griddle Grill Station for Camping, Camp, Outdoor, Tailgating, Tabletop – Stainless Steel Griddle with Knobs & Ignition, Black, 22 inch
Preview
PIT BOSS PB336GS Two Burner Portable Flat Top Griddle - Cover Included
Blackstone Tabletop Griddle, 1666, Heavy Duty Flat Top Griddle Grill Station for Camping, Camp, Outdoor, Tailgating, Tabletop – Stainless Steel Griddle with Knobs & Ignition, Black, 22 inch
Fuel
propane
propane
Burners
2
2
Total cooking area
289square inches
339 square inches
Electronic ignition
Yes
Yes
BTUs
15000BTUs
24000BTUs
Choice
PIT BOSS PB336GS Two Burner Portable Flat Top Griddle - Cover Included
Preview
PIT BOSS PB336GS Two Burner Portable Flat Top Griddle - Cover Included
Fuel
propane
Burners
2
Total cooking area
289square inches
Electronic ignition
Yes
BTUs
15000BTUs
Winner
Blackstone Tabletop Griddle, 1666, Heavy Duty Flat Top Griddle Grill Station for Camping, Camp, Outdoor, Tailgating, Tabletop – Stainless Steel Griddle with Knobs & Ignition, Black, 22 inch
Preview
Blackstone Tabletop Griddle, 1666, Heavy Duty Flat Top Griddle Grill Station for Camping, Camp, Outdoor, Tailgating, Tabletop – Stainless Steel Griddle with Knobs & Ignition, Black, 22 inch
Fuel
propane
Burners
2
Total cooking area
339 square inches
Electronic ignition
Yes
BTUs
24000BTUs

pit boss vs blackstone

FAQs About Pit Boss vs Blackstone

How long the Blackstone griddles can last?

The griddle with proper care and maintenance can last about 20 years.

Are Blackstone grills made in America?

The Blackstone grills are designed and manufactured in the USA. Their main purpose is to provide customer satisfaction and design high-quality products that can give excellent results.

Why are Blackstone griddles popular?

The Blackstone griddles have many features and advantages over other traditional grills. The large cooking top to make multiple food items at one time and easy cleanup.

Which material is used to make the pit boss griddle top?

The griddle top is made with 4.7mm thick cast iron. It is easy to sear and steak burgers and stir fry on its surface.

Are steaks easy to cook on a grill or griddle?

Steaks cooked perfectly on cast iron cooking grate.pit boss has a cast-iron surface with better heat control. Steaks can be cooked in less time and easily.

Is Blackstone Griddle Worth it?

The Blackstone griddles are definitely worth the money that you spend on them. They have a wide range of features and come with a large cooking surface, making them a reliable and high-quality piece of equipment. One of the most important things you need to consider is whether the Blackstone griddle you are purchasing meets your cooking needs perfectly.

Is Pit Boss Griddle Worth it?

Pit Boss continues to deliver disruptive products, which have remained at the forefront of the market. The biggest reason the brand stands out from the rest is that its products are extremely valuable.

Conclusion

Both griddles have many advantages. If you want to buy a durable griddle, then buy the Blackstone griddle. The pit boss has the feature of a cast iron cooking surface which retains heat. Choose the pit boss if you want to cook with a cast iron griddle.
It means then you can choose any griddle. It all depends upon your needs and preference. You should buy the griddle according to your budget and desire.

Leave a Comment